Bake It With Liv — small-batch NYC cookie shop website

Small-batch cookies · Baked fresh in NYC

Fresh cookies with a little more heart.

Premium, homemade cookie boxes baked to order for birthdays, hosting, gifting, and the sweet moments that deserve something personal.

48-hour fresh bake notice NYC pickup or delivery Gift-ready boxes

How It Works

Fresh cookies in 3 easy steps

We keep it simple so you can spend less time ordering and more time eating.

1
Fill out the order form
Choose your flavors, box size, and delivery or pickup date.
2
Liv bakes fresh
Every box is made to order — no sitting on shelves here.
3
Enjoy & share
Pickup in NYC or local delivery. Fresh, warm, and ready to love.

Place an Order

Order by DM or form

Fill out the form below and Liv will confirm your order within 24 hours.

♥ Please note: Orders need at least 48 hours notice. Payment via Venmo or Zelle after confirmation. All orders are subject to availability.

Happy Customers

Made with love, eaten with joy

Real words from real cookie lovers across NYC.

★★★★★
"These are genuinely the best cookies I've ever had. The chocolate chip is perfection — crispy edges, gooey center. I ordered for a party and everyone asked for the info!"
— Mia T., Brooklyn
★★★★★
"Ordered a gift box for my mom's birthday and she cried happy tears. The packaging was SO cute and the cookies were still soft two days later."
— Carlos R., Manhattan
★★★★★
"The brown butter snickerdoodle is life-changing. I place an order every two weeks now. Liv always responds so fast and is the sweetest!"
— Priya S., Astoria

FAQ

Good questions

Everything you need to know before you order.

How far in advance do I need to order? ▾
At least 48 hours in advance for standard orders. For large orders (24+ cookies) or custom gift boxes, please give 72 hours notice so everything is made perfectly fresh.
Do you deliver? ▾
Yes! Local delivery is available within NYC for a small $5 fee. You can also pick up at our location in NYC — pickup details are shared after your order is confirmed.
How do I pay? ▾
Payment is via Venmo or Zelle after your order is confirmed. You'll receive a confirmation DM or email with payment details within 24 hours of submitting your order form.
Do you accommodate allergies? ▾
Please note all our cookies are baked in a home kitchen that handles nuts, gluten, dairy, and eggs. We're not able to guarantee allergen-free products, but please mention any allergies in your order and we'll do our best to help.
Can I order custom or themed cookies? ▾
Absolutely! Gift boxes with custom messages, seasonal flavors, and themed packaging are all available. Just mention it in your order form and Liv will follow up with options.
How long do they stay fresh? ▾
Our cookies are best enjoyed within 3 days at room temperature. They also freeze beautifully for up to a month — just pop them in the microwave for 15 seconds to bring back that fresh-baked warmth.
Liv smiling at a table

About Liv

Meet the heart behind the cookies

Liv is a full-time graduate student studying social work, with hopes of becoming a successful therapist one day. Her passion has always been rooted in helping people feel seen, supported, and cared for. When she’s not working toward putting smiles on people’s faces in session, she’s bringing that same joy into the kitchen — baking delicious cookies made to comfort, connect, and brighten someone’s day.

Baked fresh, shared happily.